↓
 

The PolyBlog

My view from the lilypads

  • Home
  • Life
    • Family (all posts)
    • Health and Spiritualism (all posts)
    • Learning and Ideas (all posts)
    • Computers (all posts)
    • Experiences (all posts)
    • Humour (all posts)
    • Quotes (all posts)
  • Reviews
    • Books
      • Master Reading and Review List (by Author)
      • Book Reviews List (by Date of Review)
      • Book Reviews (all posts)
      • PolyWogg’s Reading Challenge
        • 2023
        • 2022
        • 2021
        • 2020
        • 2019
        • 2015, 2016, 2017
    • Movies
      • Master Movie Reviews List (by Title)
      • Movie Reviews List (by Date of Review)
      • Movie Reviews (all posts)
    • Television
      • Television Premieres (by Date of Post)
      • Television (all posts)
      • Master TV Season Reviews List (by Title)
      • TV Season Reviews List (by Date of Review)
  • Writing
    • Writing (all posts)
  • Goals
    • Goals (all posts)
    • #50by50 – Status of completion
    • PolyWogg’s Bucket List, updated for 2016
  • About Me
    • About ThePolyBlog.ca
    • Privacy Policy
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Me
    • WP colour choices
    • PolySites
      • ThePolyBlog.ca (Home)
      • PolyWogg.ca
      • AstroPontiac.ca
  • Andrea’s Corner

Tag Archives: courts

Hypocrisy viewing the court system

The PolyBlog
February 23 2016

I rarely have much interest in the public lead up to criminal trials. The trial of defendants in the court of public opinion holds no interest for me as the stories are unavoidably one-sided and thus can never resemble anything approaching truth. It’s why we hold trials, and it’s the fundamental principle of courts, trials, enquiries. While they make a decision to resolve a legal question, they are also hunting for truth, and hopefully justice. Decision, truth, and justice, and mainly in that order. They guarantee the first, try for the second, and hope for the third.

In many respects, it’s not unlike the TV shows or movies where they show a single event from multiple people’s perspectives, all of them slightly misleading, or more pointedly, highly subjective, with often a few common elements that they all saw and a list of other ones where they saw different things, missed others, or even had some that directly contradicted each other. And the court gets to figure out what “common” elements are the most “true”.

It’s the actual trial that matters to me, where a person’s one-sided view not only gets told but also tested. And so I find it fascinating to see other people’s reactions to the actual evidence when presented and tested at trials rather than just public opinion where it is just presented.

How to Make a Murderer is one of the latest fads that people railed about. Miscarriages of justice. Biased cops. Systemic discrimination. Blatant manipulation to falsify evidence. Lying. All of those things. Because the cops thought he was guilty and went after him to prove it by any means possible, apparently. And people who are often quite silent on these issues can watch the show and want to scream in fury. Shake their fists. Tilt at windmills. Because of the injustice of it all. How could a system fail to safeguard basic liberties against prosecution that borders on wilful ignorance of the presumption of innocence? Where is the justice?

Yet those same people are equally passionate about the Jian Ghomeshi trial and the court dealings of Bill Cosby. They have already decided in their mind that they are both absolutely guilty. And any cross-examination of the victims is disgusting. A miscarriage of justice. So obvious they’re guilty. Why is the system so unfair? Why don’t they change it so that the victims are automatically accepted, believed, supported? Why is there even a trial? How could a system fail to safeguard the victims against having to prove guilt to rebut a presumption of innocence? Where is the justice?

There is a saying that to hold two conflicting thoughts in your head at the same time is a mark of genius.

No, it’s not. It’s hypocrisy.

If you truly care about justice, you care about the integrity of the system for how it works for all. And the foundation of all of it, according to the original Blackstone maxim, is that “All presumptive evidence of felony should be admitted cautiously; for the law holds it better that ten guilty persons escape, than that one innocent party suffer.”

Once you accept that maxim, you can rail at the first without railing at the second. Or not rail at either if you disbelieve. But not both.

Posted in Learning and Ideas | Tagged courts, hypocrisy, justice, law, trials | Leave a reply

The sex assault trial does not go well

The PolyBlog
February 5 2016

The sex assault trial this week should be primarily about prosecutors laying the groundwork for overwhelming evidence of four crimes. For the case against Ghomeshi, the prosecutor should have the witnesses damn near bulletproof at this point. They even have their own lawyers to help them prepare. And yet, the defence attorney has picked them apart with relative ease. Not even after days of grilling, or horrendous cross-examinations that people expect. But rather, just pointing out major problems with their stories. The first complainant said he assaulted her by pulling her by the hair so hard it bent her over … Continue reading →

Posted in Learning and Ideas | Tagged courts, Ghomeshi, law, news, rape, trial | Leave a reply

2016 – the year of sexual assault trials?

The PolyBlog
January 1 2016

I was looking at various pundits predictions for 2016, and the only one that resonates with me is in the legal realm that sexual assault trials are likely to dominate major news coverage, albeit more “celebrity” / “entertainment” news than political coverage. In Canada, we’re going to see movement forward on the Jian Ghomeshi trial, and from the U.S., a potential civil and criminal trial for Bill Cosby (without prejudice to the future outcomes, I’m going to regularly refer to them as the “perpetrators” and their accusers as “victims”; I have no idea what happened with any of them). Add … Continue reading →

Posted in Learning and Ideas | Tagged Cosby, courts, Ghomeshi, law, news, rape, trial | Leave a reply

My Latest Posts

  • The Lacey Confession by Richard Greener (2006) – BR00224 (R2023) – 🐸🐸🐸🐸⚪May 22, 2023
    Plot or Premise When a rich and powerful man dies, leaving behind a lengthy and vengeful document of his life, many powerful forces move to capture the document before the document can be revealed to the public. What I Liked Whereas the first book read almost like a John Grisham novel, this second one seems … Continue reading →
  • The Knowland Retribution by Richard Greener (2004) – BR00223 (R2023) – 🐸🐸🐸🐸⚪May 14, 2023
    Plot or Premise Walter Sherman has one unique skill. He can find anything that someone is searching for, which, most of the time, is a person. His nickname is the Locator, which he earned in Vietnam. Now he earns a living doing 5-10 jobs a year when people come to him asking him to find … Continue reading →
  • McNally’s Luck by Lawrence Sanders (1992) – BR00222 (R2023) – 🐸🐸🐸⚪⚪May 8, 2023
    Plot or Premise What starts as a cat-napping morphs into poison letters, threats and murder. What I Liked There are some decent psychological elements, albeit not well-developed, and a wide cast of characters … a grieving husband vs. a trophy wife who doesn’t care about the cat; a poor poet with a rich wife; and … Continue reading →
  • McNally’s Secret by Lawrence Sanders (1992) – BR00221 (R2023) – 🐸🐸🐸🐸⚪May 7, 2023
    Plot or Premise The book is the first in the Archy McNally series. Archy is the one-man investigations unit in his father’s law firm, handling discreet investigations for Palm Beach’s wealthy locals. One of their clients has been robbed, but she doesn’t want everyone to know. She just wants her stamps back. What I Liked … Continue reading →
  • Taking a day offMay 1, 2023
    I need a mental health day tomorrow (Tuesday). I got overwhelmed today, and I’m really tired. I just don’t have the energy to adult tomorrow. I posted earlier about the progress I thought I was making on the basement. I was ready to spend a bit of time this week testing different setups to finalize … Continue reading →

Archives

Categories

© 1996-2021 - PolyWogg Privacy Policy
↑