Plot or Premise

Michael Wernick is a former Clerk of the Privy Council in Canada and his book provides advice on the “tradecraft of politics” i.e., what Prime Ministers or Ministers do or should consider doing while in office…or at least the “how” of a given day.

What I Liked

The opening was quite strong, I felt, with some good information on life from the view of being the Clerk. It had a very down-home, practical feel to it, and I was excited to see where it was going to go. I particularly liked that it was not about reform or how things “ought” to be, but stayed pretty focused on “how it (currently) works”. As Wernick notes, there are lots of other books out there that talk about reform or changes in general or comparisons of how certain leaders have governed. While much of the book is about the decisions of PMs or Ministers, I was more interested in the elements around the roles, behaviour and attitudes of political staff, as well as the operational aspects of being a DM. I particularly liked his insights into the structural imbalance that “…political offices tend to underestimate implementation risks and costs and to be impatient about timelines, whereas departments tend to be overly cautious and are likely to go to what they are familiar with as a solution.” There were also some good insights into the way Comms people view announceables or deliverables from the political side (short-term, pointed) and departmental side (potentially longer-term, incremental).

What I Didn’t Like

The middle section of the book lagged for me. What started off as down-home guidance that would benefit anyone started to read more like a memo to the PM or a Minister for a transition note. At times, it even veered somewhat into Machiavelli’s The Prince, minus the advice that it is better to be feared than loved. Yet much of that detailed or pointed behavioural advice is likely of little interest to the average reader, and I felt my interest dropping with each passing page until the DM section started.

Disclosure

While I do not know the author, I have worked closely with his sister and respect her immensely.

The Bottom Line

Great insights into the hidden world, with just a twinge of memo language.