Plot or Premise

Griswold Forsythe wants to know who is stealing valuables from around the family house.

What I Liked

Officially, Archy is there to catalog the books for insurance purposes. His real purpose — to catch a thief — is hidden. After you eliminate Griswold as a suspect, you have his wife Constance, daughter Geraldine, son and wife and granddaughter, a housekeeper, the housekeeper’s son, two maids, a chef, and a gardener. The fun is in finding out that each of them has at least one secret, sometimes several. The simple theft seems easy enough to solve, and then the stakes get raised with Griswold’s death. Was it the investigation into the thefts? Or something else…like money?

What I Didn’t Like

There is a mystery with a former polo player, some odd interactions within the family after a falling out, without much clear explanation of why the person is still around at first, and then even when revealed, it’s rather convoluted. The solution wasn’t particularly creative or interesting.

The Bottom Line

I would rather read some of the books he was cataloging