↓
 

The PolyBlog

My view from the lilypads

  • Life
    • Family (all posts)
    • Health and Spiritualism (all posts)
    • Learning and Ideas (all posts)
    • Computers (all posts)
    • Experiences (all posts)
    • Humour (all posts)
    • Quotes (all posts)
  • Reviews
    • Books
      • Book Reviews (all posts)
      • Book reviews by…
        • Book Reviews List by Date of Review
        • Book Reviews List by Number
        • Book Reviews List by Title
        • Book Reviews List by Author
        • Book Reviews List by Rating
        • Book Reviews List by Year of Publication
        • Book Reviews List by Series
      • Special collections
        • The Sherlockian Universe
        • The Three Investigators
        • The World of Nancy Drew
      • PolyWogg’s Reading Challenge
        • 2026
        • 2023
        • 2022
        • 2021
        • 2020
        • 2019
        • 2015, 2016, 2017
    • Movies
      • Master Movie Reviews List (by Title)
      • Movie Reviews List (by Date of Review)
      • Movie Reviews (all posts)
    • Music and Podcasts
      • Master Music and Podcast Reviews (by Title)
      • Music Reviews (by Date of Review)
      • Music Reviews (all posts)
      • Podcast Reviews (by Date of Review)
      • Podcast Reviews (all posts)
    • Recipes
      • Master Recipe Reviews List (by Title)
      • Recipe Reviews List (by Date of Review)
      • Recipe Reviews (all posts)
    • Television
      • Master TV Season Reviews List (by Title)
      • TV Season Reviews List (by Date of Review)
      • Television Premieres (by Date of Post)
      • Television (all posts)
  • Writing
  • Goals
    • Goals (all posts)
    • #50by50 – Status of completion
    • PolyWogg’s Bucket List, updated for 2016
  • Photo Galleries
    • PandA Gallery
    • PolyWogg AstroPhotography
    • Flickr Account
  • About Me
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Me
    • Privacy Policy
    • PolySites
      • ThePolyBlog.ca (Home)
      • PolyWogg.ca
      • AstroPontiac.ca
      • About ThePolyBlog.ca
    • WP colour choices
  • Andrea’s Corner

Tag Archives: movies

Streaming Oscar nominations for 2023

The PolyBlog
January 28 2024

Back in the day, I used to watch almost every big movie that came out. Life has changed since then, and I was looking at the list of 120 nominations that were just released that make up the main telecast. Of the 120 nominations across the 23 categories, even if I was in the industry and got a ballot card, I couldn’t have voted — I actually haven’t seen ANY of them. Yet. And every year, someone complains that the voting process is obviously flawed as many voters in the industry have not, in fact, seen all of the movies. There’s just too many, of course. Seems obvious at first blush.

But I was wondering today how many are available for streaming already and if I could watch SOME of them at least before the telecast. As I was searching through the list, I didn’t want to check availability of a movie more than once, so I did a quick spreadsheet and coloured coded movies that showed up more than once. I noticed some interesting things that I might not have noticed without the aid of a spreadsheet.

Of the long list of best picture nominees (10 instead of the long ago list of only 5), the not-surprising carry-over is that they also qualify for multiple other awards. No surprise, as I said, because, of course, if it had a good director, actor, actress, screenplay, score, or any of the other 22 categories, it had a better-than-average chance to rise up to the level of being a best picture nominee. Makes sense, right? And every year, the release of nominees includes “counts” as to how many categories the top nominee covers. 14 for this movie, only 7 for that one. So you know there is SOME repetition, of course.

But what DID surprise me is that even for just the 10 best picture nominees, they account for 71 nominations out of the 120 nominees in total. 10 pictures cover 60% of the night. And when you eliminate the ones they weren’t even eligible for (animated, documentary, shorts), that rises to 75% of the nominations. So with just watching 10 movies, a lot for some people, you could cover a huge swath of the ballot.

In fact, you would cover:

  • Best picture — all of them
  • Best director — all of them
  • Best actor — all but one (Colman Domingo for Rustin)
  • Best actress — all but one (Annette Bening for Nyad)
  • Best supporting actor — all of them
  • Best supporting actress — all but two (Danielle Brooks for The Color Purple and Jodie Foster for Nyad)
  • Best original screenplay — all but one (May December)
  • Best adapted screenplay — all of them
  • Best cinematography — all but one (El Conde)
  • Best costume design — all but one (Napoleon)
  • Best makeup and hairstyling — all but two (Golda and Society of the Snow)
  • Best original song — all but two (from Flamin’ Hot and American Symphony)
  • Best original score — all but one (Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny)
  • Best production design — all but one (Napoleon)
  • Best film editing — all of them
  • Best sound — all but two (The Creator and Mission: Impossible Dead Reckoning Part I
  • Best visual effects — none of the five but only two aren’t covered already by the previous additions

What does that mean? It means if you take the 10 best picture nominees, add in Rustin, Nyad, The Color Purple, May December, El Conde, Napoleon, Golda, Society of the Snow, Flamin’ Hot and American Symphony, plus the other four that are visual effects (Napoleon plus Creator, Godzilla, Mission: Impossible, Guardians of the Galaxy), you get all 95 of the main nominees in just 10 + 10 + 4 = 24 movies. Sure, the animated and docs and shorts don’t have a lot of overlaps, almost 25 there too but it wouldn’t really be fair to suggest it’s covering 50 movies. Not really.

I find it particularly telling that if you JUST use the top four categories, you’d get to 12 movies; add in supporting, it jumps to 13 movies; and 14 would cover everything down to cinematography plus film editing. That’s almost doable in a month if you were hardcore.

Hence my curiosity as to what is available in streaming format at the moment. I looked them up on JustWatch.com to see what was available and what wasn’t…If they were available with a subscription, I said “Apple”, “Netflix”, “Prime”, “Disney”, “Crave”, “Paramount”. If they were available only to buy or rent, I added a $ after each one. Here is the full list, if interested.

AwardMovieAppleNetflixPrimeDisneyOtherNominee
Best PictureAmerican Fiction—————American Fiction (Ben LeClair, Nikos Karamigios, Cord Jefferson and Jermaine Johnson, Producers)
Best PictureAnatomy of a Fall Apple $—Amazon $——Anatomy of a Fall (Marie-Ange Luciani and David Thion, Producers)
Best PictureBarbieApple $ Amazon $ CraveBarbie (David Heyman, Margot Robbie, Tom Ackerley and Robbie Brenner, Producers)
Best PictureThe Holdovers Apple $—Amazon $——The Holdovers (Mark Johnson, Producer)
Best PictureKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Killers of the Flower Moon (Dan Friedkin, Bradley Thomas, Martin Scorsese and Daniel Lupi, Producers)
Best PictureMaestro —Netflix———Maestro (Bradley Cooper, Steven Spielberg, Fred Berner, Amy Durning and Kristie Macosko Krieger, Producers)
Best PictureOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Emma Thomas, Charles Roven and Christopher Nolan, Producers)
Best PicturePast Lives Apple $ Amazon $  Past Lives (David Hinojosa, Christine Vachon and Pamela Koffler, Producers)
Best PicturePoor Things —————Poor Things (Ed Guiney, Andrew Lowe, Yorgos Lanthimos and Emma Stone, Producers)
Best PictureThe Zone of Interest —————The Zone of Interest (James Wilson, Producer)
Best DirectingAnatomy of a Fall Apple $—Amazon $——Justine Triet (Anatomy of a Fall)
Best DirectingKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Martin Scorsese (Killers of the Flower Moon)
Best DirectingOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Christopher Nolan (Oppenheimer)
Best DirectingPoor Things —————Yorgos Lanthimos (Poor Things)
Best DirectingThe Zone of Interest —————Jonathan Glazer (The Zone of Interest)
Best Actor in a Leading RoleMaestro —Netflix———Bradley Cooper (Maestro)
Best Actor in a Leading RoleRustin Netflix   Colman Domingo (Rustin)
Best Actor in a Leading RoleThe Holdovers Apple $—Amazon $——Paul Giamatti (The Holdovers)
Best Actor in a Leading RoleOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Cillian Murphy (Oppenheimer)
Best Actor in a Leading RoleAmerican Fiction—————Jeffrey Wright (American Fiction)
Best Actress in a Leading RoleNyad—Netflix———Annette Bening (Nyad)
Best Actress in a Leading RoleKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Lily Gladstone (Killers of the Flower Moon)
Best Actress in a Leading RoleAnatomy of a Fall Apple $—Amazon $——Sandra HΓΌller (Anatomy of a Fall)
Best Actress in a Leading RoleMaestro —Netflix———Carey Mulligan (Maestro)
Best Actress in a Leading RolePoor Things —————Emma Stone (Poor Things)
Best Actor in a Supporting RoleAmerican Fiction—————Sterling K. Brown (American Fiction)
Best Actor in a Supporting RoleKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Robert De Niro (Killers of the Flower Moon)
Best Actor in a Supporting RoleOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Robert Downey Jr. (Oppenheimer)
Best Actor in a Supporting RoleBarbieApple $ Amazon $ CraveRyan Gosling (Barbie)
Best Actor in a Supporting RolePoor Things —————Mark Ruffalo (Poor Things)
Best Actress in a Supporting RoleOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Emily Blunt (Oppenheimer)
Best Actress in a Supporting RoleThe Color PurpleApple $—Amazon $——Danielle Brooks (The Color Purple)
Best Actress in a Supporting RoleBarbieApple $ Amazon $ CraveAmerica Ferrera (Barbie)
Best Actress in a Supporting RoleNyad—Netflix———Jodie Foster (Nyad)
Best Actress in a Supporting RoleThe Holdovers Apple $—Amazon $——Da’Vine Joy Randolph (The Holdovers)
Best Writing (Adapted Screenplay)American Fiction—————American Fiction (Written for the screen by Cord Jefferson)
Best Writing (Adapted Screenplay)BarbieApple $ Amazon $ CraveBarbie (Written by Greta Gerwig & Noah Baumbach)
Best Writing (Adapted Screenplay)Oppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Written for the screen by Christopher Nolan)
Best Writing (Adapted Screenplay)Poor Things —————Poor Things (Screenplay by Tony McNamara)
Best Writing (Adapted Screenplay)The Zone of Interest —————The Zone of Interest (Written by Jonathan Glazer)
Best Writing (Original Screenplay)Anatomy of a Fall Apple $—Amazon $——Anatomy of a Fall (Screenplay by Justine Triet and Arthur Harari)
Best Writing (Original Screenplay)The Holdovers Apple $—Amazon $——The Holdovers (Written by David Hemingson)
Best Writing (Original Screenplay)Maestro —Netflix———Maestro (Written by Bradley Cooper & Josh Singer)
Best Writing (Original Screenplay)May December—Netflix———May December (Screenplay by Samy Burch; Story by Samy Burch & Alex Mechanik)
Best Writing (Original Screenplay)Past Lives Apple $ Amazon $  Past Lives (Written by Celine Song)
Best Animated FeatureThe Boy and the Heron—————The Boy and the Heron (Hayao Miyazaki and Toshio Suzuki)
Best Animated FeatureElementalApple $—Amazon $Disney—Elemental (Peter Sohn and Denise Ream)
Best Animated FeatureNimona—Netflix———Nimona (Nick Bruno, Troy Quane, Karen Ryan and Julie Zackary)
Best Animated FeatureRobot Dreams—————Robot Dreams (Pablo Berger, Ibon Cormenzana, Ignasi EstapΓ© and Sandra Tapia DΓ­az)
Best Animated FeatureSpider-ManApple $ Amazon $  Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (Kemp Powers, Justin K. Thompson, Phil Lord, Christopher Miller and Amy Pascal)
Best Documentary Feature FilmBobi Wine———Disney—Bobi Wine: The People’s President (Moses Bwayo, Christopher Sharp and John Battsek)
Best Documentary Feature FilmEternal Memory—————The Eternal Memory (Nominees to be determined)
Best Documentary Feature FilmFour Daughters—————Four Daughters (Kaouther Ben Hania and Nadim Cheikhrouha)
Best Documentary Feature FilmTo Kill A Tiger————NFBTo Kill a Tiger (Nisha Pahuja, Cornelia Principe and David Oppenheim)
Best Documentary Feature Film20 Days in Mariupol————Google $20 Days in Mariupol (Mstyslav Chernov, Michelle Mizner and Raney Aronson-Rath)
Best International Feature FilmIo Capitano—————Io Capitano (Italy)
Best International Feature FilmPerfect Days—————Perfect Days (Japan)
Best International Feature FilmSociety of the Snow—Netflix———Society of the Snow (Spain)
Best International Feature FilmThe Teacher’s Lounge—————The Teacher’s Lounge (Germany)
Best International Feature FilmThe Zone of Interest —————The Zone of Interest (United Kingdom)
Best Animated Short FilmLetter to a Pig—————Letter to a Pig (Tal Kantor and Amit R. Gicelter)
Best Animated Short FilmNinety-Five Senses—————Ninety-Five Senses (Jerusha Hess and Jared Hess)
Best Animated Short FilmOur Uniform—————Our Uniform (Yegane Moghaddam)
Best Animated Short FilmPachyderme—————Pachyderme (StΓ©phanie ClΓ©ment and Marc Rius)
Best Animated Short FilmWar is Over!—————War Is Over! Inspired by the Music of John & Yoko (Dave Mullins and Brad Booker)
Best Live-Action Short FilmThe After—Netflix———The After (Misan Harriman and Nicky Bentham)
Best Live-Action Short FilmInvincible—————Invincible (Vincent RenΓ©-Lortie and Samuel Caron)
Best Live-Action Short FilmNight of Fortune—————Knight of Fortune (Lasse Lyskjaer Noer and Christian Norlyk)
Best Live-Action Short FilmRed, White and Blue—————Red, White and Blue (Nazrin Choudhury and Sara McFarlane)
Best Live-Action Short FilmThe Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar—Netflix———The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar (Wes Anderson and Steven Rales)
Best Documentary Short FilmThe ABCs of Book Banning————ParamountThe ABCs of Book Banning (Sheila Nevins and Trish Adlesic)
Best Documentary Short FilmThe Barber of Little Rock—————The Barber of Little Rock (John Hoffman and Christine Turner)
Best Documentary Short FilmIsland In Between—————Island in Between (S. Leo Chiang and Jean Tsien)
Best Documentary Short FilmThe Last Repair Shop———Disney—The Last Repair Shop (Ben Proudfoot and Kris Bowers)
Best Documentary Short FilmNai Nai & Wai Po—————Nǎi Nai & WΓ i PΓ³ (Sean Wang and Sam Davis)
Best CinematographyEl Conde—Netflix———El Conde (Edward Lachman)
Best CinematographyKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Killers of the Flower Moon (Rodrigo Prieto)
Best CinematographyMaestro —Netflix———Maestro (Matthew Libatique)
Best CinematographyOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Hoyte van Hoytema)
Best CinematographyPoor Things —————Poor Things (Robbie Ryan)
Best Costume DesignBarbieApple $ Amazon $ CraveBarbie (Jacqueline Durran)
Best Costume DesignKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Killers of the Flower Moon (Jacqueline West)
Best Costume DesignNapoleon——Amazon $——Napoleon (Janty Yates and Dave Crossman)
Best Costume DesignOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Ellen Mirojnick)
Best Costume DesignPoor Things —————Poor Things (Holly Waddington)
Best Makeup and HairstylingGoldaApple $—Amazon——Golda (Karen Hartley Thomas, Suzi Battersby and Ashra Kelly-Blue)
Best Makeup and HairstylingMaestro —Netflix———Maestro (Kazu Hiro, Kay Georgiou and Lori McCoy-Bell)
Best Makeup and HairstylingOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Luisa Abel)
Best Makeup and HairstylingPoor Things —————Poor Things (Nadia Stacey, Mark Coulier and Josh Weston)
Best Makeup and HairstylingSociety of the Snow—Netflix———Society of the Snow (Ana LΓ³pez-Puigcerver, David MartΓ­ and Montse RibΓ©)
Best Original SongFlamin’ Hot———Disney—β€œThe Fire Inside” from Flamin’ Hot (Music and Lyric by Diane Warren)
Best Original SongBarbieApple $ Amazon $ Craveβ€œI’m Just Ken” from Barbie (Music and Lyric by Mark Ronson and Andrew Wyatt)
Best Original SongAmerican Symphony—Netflix———β€œIt Never Went Away” from American Symphony (Music and Lyric by Jon Batiste and Dan Wilson)
Best Original SongKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——β€œWahzhazhe (A Song for My People)” from Killers of the Flower Moon (Music and Lyric by Scott George)
Best Original SongBarbieApple $ Amazon $ Craveβ€œWhat Was I Made For?” from Barbie (Music and Lyric by Billie Eilish and Finneas O’Connell)
Best Original ScoreAmerican Fiction—————American Fiction (Laura Karpman)
Best Original ScoreIndiana Jones and the Dial of DestinyApple $—Amazon $Disney—Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny (John Williams)
Best Original ScoreKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Killers of the Flower Moon (Robbie Robertson)
Best Original ScoreOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Ludwig GΓΆransson)
Best Original ScorePoor Things —————Poor Things (Jerskin Fendrix)
Best Production DesignBarbieApple $ Amazon $ CraveBarbie (Production Design: Sarah Greenwood; Set Decoration: Katie Spencer)
Best Production DesignKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Killers of the Flower Moon (Production Design: Jack Fisk; Set Decoration: Adam Willis)
Best Production DesignNapoleon——Amazon $——Napoleon (Production Design: Arthur Max; Set Decoration: Elli Griff)
Best Production DesignOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Production Design: Ruth De Jong; Set Decoration: Claire Kaufman)
Best Production DesignPoor Things —————Poor Things (Production Design: James Price and Shona Heath; Set Decoration: Zsuzsa Mihalek)
Best Film EditingAnatomy of a Fall Apple $—Amazon $——Anatomy of a Fall (Laurent SΓ©nΓ©chal)
Best Film EditingThe Holdovers Apple $—Amazon $——The Holdovers (Kevin Tent)
Best Film EditingKillers of the Flower MoonApple—Amazon $——Killers of the Flower Moon (Thelma Schoonmaker)
Best Film EditingOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Jennifer Lame)
Best Film EditingPoor Things —————Poor Things (Yorgos Mavropsaridis)
Best SoundThe CreatorApple $—Amazon $Disney—The Creator (Ian Voigt, Erik Aadahl, Ethan Van der Ryn, Tom Ozanich and Dean Zupancic)
Best SoundMaestro —Netflix———Maestro (Steven A. Morrow, Richard King, Jason Ruder, Tom Ozanich and Dean Zupancic)
Best SoundMission: Impossible Dead ReckoningApple $—Amazon $—ParamountMission: Impossible β€” Dead Reckoning Part One (Chris Munro, James H. Mather, Chris Burdon and Mark Taylor)
Best SoundOppenheimer Apple $—Amazon $——Oppenheimer (Willie Burton, Richard King, Gary A. Rizzo and Kevin O’Connell)
Best SoundThe Zone of Interest —————The Zone of Interest (Tarn Willers and Johnnie Burn)
Best Visual EffectsThe CreatorApple $—Amazon $Disney—The Creator (Jay Cooper, Ian Comley, Andrew Roberts and Neil Corbould)
Best Visual EffectsGodzilla: Minus One—————Godzilla: Minus One (Takashi Yamazaki, Kiyoko Shibuya, Masaki Takahashi and Tatsuji Nojima)
Best Visual EffectsThe Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 3Apple $——Disney—Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 (Stephane Ceretti, Alexis Wajsbrot, Guy Williams and Theo Bialek)
Best Visual EffectsMission: Impossible Dead ReckoningApple $—Amazon $—ParamountMission: Impossible β€” Dead Reckoning, Part One (Alex Wuttke, Simone Coco, Jeff Sutherland and Neil Corbould)
Best Visual EffectsNapoleon——Amazon $——Napoleon (Charley Henley, Luc-Ewen Martin-Fenouillet, Simone Coco and Neil Corbould)

So, where does that leave me? Of the 53 overall titles in the long list…

Available to watch with a subscription to a specific streaming service (23)

  • The ABCs of Book Banning
  • The After
  • American Symphony
  • Barbie
  • Bobi Wine
  • El Conde
  • The Creator
  • Elemental
  • Flamin’ Hot
  • Golda
  • The Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 3
  • Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny
  • Killers of the Flower Moon
  • The Last Repair Shop
  • MaestroΒ 
  • May December
  • Mission: Impossible Dead Reckoning
  • Nimona
  • Nyad
  • Rustin
  • Society of the Snow
  • To Kill A Tiger
  • The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar

Available to buy or rent online (8)

  • 20 Days in Mariupol
  • Anatomy of a FallΒ 
  • The Color Purple
  • The HoldoversΒ 
  • Napoleon
  • OppenheimerΒ 
  • Past LivesΒ 
  • Spider-Man

Not available to stream (22)

  • American Fiction
  • The Barber of Little Rock
  • The Boy and the Heron
  • Eternal Memory
  • Four Daughters
  • Godzilla: Minus One
  • Invincible
  • Io Capitano
  • Island In Between
  • Letter to a Pig
  • Nai Nai & Wai Po
  • Night of Fortune
  • Ninety-Five Senses
  • Our Uniform
  • Pachyderme
  • Perfect Days
  • Poor ThingsΒ 
  • Red, White and Blue
  • Robot Dreams
  • The Teacher’s Lounge
  • War is Over!
  • The Zone of InterestΒ 

I found it interesting making the spreadsheet. My impression was that there were WAY more that were available to rent or buy online than already free through a subscription service. Except that certain movies over-represented early because almost ALL of the ones available ANYWHERE are ALSO available on Apple or Amazon for rent or buy…they just happen to ALSO be available if you already have a subscription.

For the ones that are not available ANYWHERE, a large number of them are short or animated or documentaries, or some combination therein. I thought they might be available on YouTube, but not yet. I set up some alerts to let me know if/when they show up on a streaming service.

Okay then, my list is set.

Posted in Movie Reviews | Tagged movies, oscars | Leave a reply

Sharing and ranking my reviews

The PolyBlog
February 23 2019

Back when I started doing reviews, I shared them by email with some friends and other people who asked to be put on the list after seeing other things I emailed out for PolyWogg Trivia and PW-Humour. I was an one-man GoogleGroups of sorts.

I had dreams of becoming semi-famous as an online blogger for movies. I tried posting a few reviews to various sites, and a site called Ottawa FilmCan loved my reviews — free content for them! So when studios offered them “press passes” for some premiere, they gave one to me. I went to the theatre, got in for free, and sat in a decent row where five of the seats said “reserved for press”. Me, with a press pass for a movie? Cool. I didn’t get a lot of free passes, but just enough that it remained a rush each time.

At the time, I was going to the movies fairly regularly, mostly by myself, and I tried to go to some premieres several times a year. So my reviews would show up within a day or two of a premiere. Sometimes I could even post them on the Friday night after seeing the 7:00 p.m. show. It was fun, and started posting my review links to IMDB.com as well, at a time when there weren’t a lot of people doing that. You couldn’t post directly, just your link, and online review sites tended to ONLY accept professional reviewers like Siskel and Ebert. There was no Rotten Tomatoes site and nobody had thought yet about collating reviews or ratings from the unwashed masses.

I moved into doing some book reviews too, or more accurately, moved into actually sharing them by something other than email, and when Amazon went live, I thought, “Hey, I could do book reviews for THEM!”. At the time, anyone with more than 100 or so reviews up was almost guaranteed to be in the top 20 reviewers on the site, and they were only soliciting and accepting book reviews at the time (not product reviews). I posted 50 or so and made it in the top 100 list for reviewers.

I had dreams of eventually getting books for free from publishers, as well as movies as screeners on DVD. But it’s a young person’s game, so to speak, before life intervenes and sucks your free time. You need to not only produce extensively to attract interest, you also have to do a lot of self-promotion and marketing. I couldn’t sustain that level, nor did I have much interest in the life of what people now do as celebrity Youtubers and social media stars even if it was on a much smaller scale. I had no entrepreneurial drive to turn it anything more than a hobby to guarantee those ongoing perks.

Over the last ten years, I’ve focused on my blog, and did occasional reviews when I got around to it. I managed to go through all my old book reviews, format them for the new site, and even write another 50 or so. I expanded to Amazon.CA when the Canadian site opened, and then expanded outward to lots of sites. I really don’t have a strong reason why at this point, but I post to Amazon (Canada, US), Indigo, Kobo, Ottawa Public Library (added recently), Barnes and Noble, Library Thing, Good Reads and Google. I did Shelfari for awhile too, but alas, it died. And as always, my own website. I’m not after free books or screeners (although I wouldn’t say no to the latter), but I love when people comment on my reviews to agree or disagree. People around the world that I don’t even KNOW. Still a bit of the rush of when I used to get press passes. Maybe some sort of external validation thing, I guess.

As I said, I ranked high on Amazon.com early on and even stayed there for a time when I had less than 50 in total, but that was solely based on number of reviews. Over time, people started posting reviews of limited length (i.e. “Good book, you should read”) which are worthless in my view. There are RABID onliners who have views about those types of reviews, and from both ends of the spectrum — many who think (as I do) that it hardly qualifies as a review as it doesn’t tell you anything other than “Yum” for a restaurant or recipe vs. others who think it qualifies as censorship or snobbery to put any limits on what constitutes a review. Regardless, Amazon changed up the algorithms eventually based on whether people rated a review as “helpful” or not.

Recently, I got curious though, as I passed the 125 review mark for my book reviews. Where do I rank now?

It took me a bit to find the reviewer ranking in my Amazon profiles, but I am at the 400K (!) position on Amazon.com and 19K on Amazon.ca. A far cry from any “top” positions. However, that is not surprising since I tend to rate older books, not new releases, which means very few people are going to see them shortly after a book’s release and click “helpful” (you get the most clicks for that when there are less than 10 reviews, particularly when I do a decent review of some length compared to the “read it last week” reviews, which don’t tend to get many “helpful” votes).

I can’t seem to find a list of how I’m doing in terms of raw numbers anymore though. When I review the list of “top reviewers” now though I see that the list varies considerably in how many reviews they have. Some have as few as a couple of hundred, some as many as 10K. However, when I look at the 10K ones, their reviews are almost always REALLY short, four stars and above, and some of the first to ever appear. Yeah, cuz that seems legit. Particularly for accounts active less than at least five years.

It’s one of the complaints about Amazon reviews, how the integrity has been compromised over the years by scammers and if I go to the Top Reviewers Hall of Fame area, there are a number who are listed who now have ZERO votes and ZERO reviews. Why? Almost all of them have deleted their reviews in disgust, or to monetize them elsewhere themselves, or in rare occasions, because Amazon killed their accounts! But I digress. I only have 120+ reviews on Amazon US and about 150+ on Amazon Canada, with the difference being that Amazon Canada also includes some product reviews (electronics, etc.), all verified purchases. For my books, while most of my ebook purchases come from Amazon, not all of them do. Some are just library loans, but I still post the review everywhere.

Over at Good Reads, they also go by “votes” on your reviews, but those numbers are driven by two things. First, it helps to give your reviews as early as possible for new releases so that people considering a book will see your review in the first five or six — get your review in early, and they’ll upvote you, same as on Amazon.

However, second, Good Reads encourages you to link to other people on the site — i.e. creating friend links like on FB — and a lot of them find those friends through Twitter-like reciprocity…they “like” anybody they can find and are liked back. Or they interact through discussions. Either way, they “link” to each other and thus any review one of them does, it instantly generates eyeballs and clicks. Think of it as a way of using the site to create your own following. Amazon doesn’t really do that in the same way, but Good Reads does.

Many of the top 20 reviewers on Good Reads have maxed out their account with 5000 friends. The lead, a woman named Emily, has 10K followers on her page on FB too. That requires not only effort to sustain but also a lot of effort at self-promotion, as I mentioned earlier. More power to her, but not my cup of tea. As a measure of her power, she has 500K votes on Good Reads, with the person in number 2 position being less than 300K. Wow. And she has that following from ~1500 reviews. I don’t know if all of her reviews are as long as the few I sampled, but she has a breezy style and doesn’t seem to post short ones…she talks about the book in some length, putting up > 200 books a year. The Top Canadian, Lola, read about 250 books in 2018, with 160K votes over the years. My ranking is so low, I don’t even register, but I don’t self-promote either. Hmm, I should probably think about that a little. Even if I just put my links on my blog too (I’ve recently started using their API to gather the book image and then link to the individual review overall).

Over at Chapters, I can’t seem to find a list of Top Reviewers. Heck, it’s even difficult to FIND my profile to see that I have 89 reviews with a whopping — wait for it — six votes. Yeah, pretty sure that’s not going to lead to any recognition. πŸ™‚ On their sister site, Kobo, I can’t even find a list of my reviews nor any rankings. I pulled up one of my old reviews, and it doesn’t even let me click on my name to show me ANY info if I wanted to see other reviews by the same person. That is a huge missed opportunity for them.

For Barnes and Noble, they’ve linked their paperback and NOOK reviews, same as Amazon has with Kindle, and like Chapters, it’s almost impossible to track reviews of any one reviewer. I suppose I could get to it through a complicated Google Search of the site. I can’t even find out how many reviews I have posted there, and I wrote them!

Over at Google Books, it’s the same thing. I can see my individual reviews (i.e. if I go to a book I already reviewed), but there is no easy way to see all my reviews nor for others to see my profile. There are opportunities for upvoting, but it doesn’t seem to track it in any way.

Library Thing is a lot like Good Reads, but not as well developed for interactivity and rankings. I am not thrilled with the interface at all, including how to add books to my list in order to review them quickly, but that may just be a simple workflow tweak I haven’t seen yet. The site does however give a lot of stats about the books in your “library” and different ways to sort and see the data.

Finally, last but not least, I started sharing my reviews with the Ottawa Public Library. I have 145 “community credits”, which you get for doing various things like rating a book or submitting a comment (i.e. a review). Can you DO anything with credits? No, but it’s a bit of gamification I guess. I don’t see anyway to share my lists though as anything other than an RSS feed. And no way to search across other feeds.

For movies and TV, the world is simpler. I only post at 6 sites:

  • Internet Movie Database (IMDB): TV series reviews and rating, TV episode reviews and ratings, movie reviews and ratings;
  • The Movie Database (TMDB): TV series reviews and ratings, TV episode ratings, movie reviews and atings;
  • Rotten Tomatoes: TV season rating and review, movie review and rating;
  • MetaCritic: TV season rating and review, movie review and rating;
  • TV.COM: TV series reviews and ratings, TV episode ratings;
  • TVFanatic: TV episode ratings;

And I have absolutely NO idea about rankings within those sites.

I won’t get famous, that’s for sure. But I like doing it.

Posted in Book Reviews | Tagged book review, books, movies, reviews, sites | Leave a reply

2015 – New areas of writing

The PolyBlog
January 4 2015

The seventh item on my vaguebooking list was “07. Seven new topics”. These are new “subject areas” that I want to write about on my blog.

Pop culture is likely one of them, although it might be more narrow than that, maybe “pop culture intersecting with the news”. I didn’t comment on Jian Ghomeshi or Bill Cosby’s news items when they hit, but I loved watching people post and take sides, often looking like internet trolls in comment forums except they were posting the same comments on their own social media feeds. My take is a bit different and is primarily about the law, and the court of public opinion vs. the court of justice or law. I may yet blog about it.

Equally, I love the law. So much so that I couldn’t become a lawyer. I’d like to take a subject area and blog about that, but I haven’t yet found my niche. It may very well harken back to my days at law school when I was working for the Ministry of Education in B.C. and focus on the law, schools, education, and children. I haven’t quite decided yet. But there’s an itch there that I’d like to scratch again.

In the realm of writing, I have three areas that are of interest to me. First and foremost is the changing nature of the business model of publishing. I’m very much in the world where “everyone must choose their own path”, and I may turn my attention again to the world of disrupted publishing. Second, I think there is a lot of general information out there about marketing of books in the modern age, but not a lot that gives a comprehensive list of “here’s everything you COULD do, choose wisely”. I started work on this at one time and would like to go back to it. Finally, I also think there is a ripe area for a different slant on books and publishing, and that’s measuring the performance of libraries. I did some research and even some preliminary writing about three years ago but never brought anything to fruition. I think libraries are going to come under increased fire in the digital age, and while they have a strong role to play, I don’t think many of them are telling the right story or using the right yardsticks. When they tell their story initially, they act as a community centre; when their funding is threatened, they claim critics are burning books and destroying literacy if the library goes the way of the dodo. The balance is off, and maybe I can find something I can contribute to the conversation.

In a similar vein, I’m wondering if I have something to say about charities. I feel that much of the rhetoric out there is a bit one-sided, or at times, diametrically-opposed two-sided. I know, for example, that there is not much out there giving people insights into different types of charities. I also have some questions for myself that I want answered on local basic human needs programming and the most effective means of contributing donor dollars.

Finally, I do reviews for books, movies, TV and music, or at least my website says I do. I’ve been a slacker-doodle for my reviews, and I want to get back into them. I am not yet ready to commit to exactly what the other six categories will look like when I’m done, but I know this one pretty well. So, I commit to:

  • 24 book reviews;
  • 250 reviews of TV episodes (tweets);
  • 24 movie reviews; and,
  • 3 new reviews of Billboard year-end results.

That should keep me busy too.

Posted in Goals | Tagged 2015, books, charities, culture, education, goals, law, libraries, movies, music, pop, pricing, publishing, reviews, self-promotion, tv, website | Leave a reply

Countdown to Retirement

Days

Hours

Minutes

Seconds

Retirement!

My Latest Posts

  • QotD: Tell your stories (PWQ00061)January 14, 2026
  • 2026: K is for kayakJanuary 14, 2026
    I was having trouble deciding what to write for “K”. Kayak is an obvious one, although I’ll come back to that in a moment. I considered going whimsical with kicking back or being kooky. Some sort of cute title that suggests that I shouldn’t take myself so seriously and instead try to find some silly … Continue reading →
  • The Dying Hour by Rick Mofina (2005) – BR00292 (R2026) – 🐸🐸🐸βšͺβšͺJanuary 14, 2026
    Plot or Premise A college student drives off suddenly into the night, never to be seen again, while her car is found abandoned at the side of the road. Did she meet someone? Walk off into the woods? Commit suicide? What I Liked The main part is Jason Wade, a reporter who starts to link … Continue reading →
  • QotD: Fixing pages (PWQ00060)January 13, 2026
  • JotD: Poor nuns (PWH00050)January 13, 2026

Archives

Categories

© 1996-2025 - PolyWogg Privacy Policy
↑